How we compare protein powders
Every number on this site comes from a maker's label or a store page, with the date we read it. This page shows the rules and the sums.
The carb rule
A powder is listed when its label shows at most 3 g of total carbohydrate per 25 g of declared protein. This is our own editorial rule. It is not an official definition and not diet advice. In the comparison you can pick 0, 1, 2, 3 or 5 g, or type your own limit.
We use total carbs, not net carbs. We do not subtract fiber or sugar alcohols.
A US label may show 0 g when a serving has under 0.5 g. So “0 g on the label” means what the label says, not a lab result.
The sums, with a real example
Example: Naked Nutrition Naked Pea, Unflavored, 5LB (2,268 g).
The label says: serving 30g (About 2 scoops), protein 27 g, total carbohydrate 2 g.
- Carbs per 25 g protein = 25 × carbs ÷ protein = 25 × 2 ÷ 27 = 1.9 g.
- Protein per 100 g of powder = 100 × protein ÷ serving weight = 90.0 g.
- 25 g portions of protein in the pack = pack weight × protein per 100 g ÷ 100 ÷ 25 = 2,268 g × 90.0 g ÷ 100 ÷ 25.
- Cost per 25 g protein = item price ÷ portions = $57.99 ÷ that number = $0.71. Price seen Nov 17, 2026.
We calculate with the full numbers and round only for display: carbs to one decimal, money to the cent.
“Declared protein” means the protein the label states. It is not a measure of how much your body absorbs.
Where each number comes from
- Nutrition, ingredients and pack size: the maker's US product page and label image, read by hand.
- Prices: the store's own product page or the store's own product data, with the date we read it. One store blocks automatic reading, so we link to it without a price. A price that needs a second check is held back.
- Claims such as “vegan”: copied in the maker's exact words, with a link. We did not check them.
- We never fill a gap with numbers from another flavor, size or market.
How old a price may be
A price older than 7 days is not shown and not ranked. The button then says “Check price at” the store. We check the age when the site is built and again when you open the page, if your browser runs JavaScript. With JavaScript off, check the “price seen” date next to each price.
Only one-time prices and sale prices with no condition are ranked. Subscription, coupon, first-order and member prices are shown apart, with a label, and never ranked.
We show the item price before tax. Shipping is not verified for any store. When a store page names a free shipping threshold, we quote it and do not count it as free.
How we sort
Default: cost per 25 g of declared protein, item price only, lowest first. Ties within a cent go to fewer carbs, then to newer label data, then A to Z. A label that only says “less than” gives an upper bound, not a value, so it sorts after the exact values. Packs without a current price come last, sorted by carbs. You can also sort by carbs, lowest first.
Commissions, stores and affiliate status never change the order.
When data is missing or unclear
- No shipping data: “Shipping not verified”. No total is implied.
- The full ingredient list names no sweetener: "No sweetener listed in the checked ingredients". This says nothing about allergens.
- The ingredient list is incomplete: “Ingredients incomplete”, and the “No sweetener listed” filter leaves the powder out.
- The label says “less than 1 g”: we keep it as an upper bound (“under”). It passes a limit only when the bound is below the limit.
- Two sources disagree: the number they disagree on leaves the cost ranking until it is settled.
Settled so far:
- Naked Pea, 1LB (454 g): Net weight from the maker's size name (1LB), the same basis as the 5LB size. The other value (680 g) is the shop's shipping weight field.
- Naked Pea, 2LB (907 g): Net weight from the maker's size name (2LB), the same basis as the 5LB size. The other value (1021 g) is the shop's shipping weight field.
- High Whey Protein Powder, 12.7 OZ (360g): Net weight from the label photo (Net Weight 12.7 OZ (360g)). The other value (454 g) is the shop's shipping weight field.
What we did not do
We did not test, taste, mix or bake with any powder. We did not send anything to a lab. We make no health, weight-loss or keto claims.
Found a wrong number? Tell us.